When you manage memberships, dealing with issues like low retention, low engagement, poor event turnout, or community difficulties can be a tough ask.

The list of such issues seems endless, and you have to deal with them anyway. However, it’s necessary to identify the most important challenges to address so your resources and energy are not wasted on less impactful areas. 

Therefore, in this blog post, we’ll help you pinpoint these key challenges and provide effective solutions. 

Explore the insights and discover how to focus your efforts on what truly matters.

Key Takeaways

• Member retention and engagement are crucial for growth. Without active involvement, members are likely to leave.
• Time-consuming tasks like invoicing and data entry slow down productivity. Automation helps eliminate inefficiencies.
• Centralized and up-to-date data ensures better decision-making and improves member relationships.
• Organizations need modern tools to streamline operations and meet member expectations.
• Glue Up provides an all-in-one solution to manage memberships, events, and communication efficiently, boosting organizational growth.

The Biggest Membership Management Challenges

Membership management presents various challenges. Some can be addressed over time, while others demand immediate attention to prevent a negative impact on your organization’s growth and member satisfaction. 

Here are the biggest challenges that you simply can’t ignore and need to resolve without delay:

Member Retention

Retaining members is a top priority for organizations. Many associations aim for a retention rate of 75% or higher, meaning at least 750 out of 1,000 members should renew each year. Yet, many struggle to meet this benchmark, highlighting the seriousness of the issue for member organizations. 

This challenge makes retention even more critical than acquiring new members. Poor retention often signals that members don’t see value in the association, lack loyalty, or face unresolved issues, which is an alarming situation that requires immediate attention.

Addressing these retention challenges isn’t just necessary; it’s transformative.

Member Engagement

Image

Keeping members engaged isn’t always easy, but it should never be overlooked. Engagement is the foundation of members finding value in your organization. The more engaged a member is, the stronger their connection, making them feel a sense of belonging. 

That’s why engaged members stay an average of 4 more years compared with non-engaged members. When members stop participating, it often signals they no longer see value in your association, whether they feel it’s no longer relevant or they’re seeking better alternatives. 

For them to stay, their active involvement is essential; otherwise, losing them becomes inevitable.

The reasons for disengagement can vary. Perhaps members lack the platforms and features they need to engage effectively. Irrelevant discussions may dominate, discouraging participation, or the absence of exclusive groups and discussion forums may leave members feeling disconnected. 

Ultimately, engagement is more than a buzzword; it’s the driving force behind long-term member loyalty. 

Data Management

Poor data management will derail your operations. If you are unable to organize your member data, every decision you make will be shaky. 

As Clive Humby famously said, "Data is the new oil," emphasizing its value in driving decisions and operations, so you must know how to contain and manage your oil and capitalize on it.

However, with increasing volumes of data scattered across multiple systems, organizations find it difficult to manage it efficiently. For example, if you fail to integrate member activity data with communication tools, it can lead to poorly targeted outreach, low engagement, and missed opportunities for retention. 

Notably, 75% of major enterprises have reported significant problems due to defective data, and 33% have failed to bill or collect receivables. These stats illustrate how poor data management can directly impact both operational efficiency and revenue generation. 

Manual Processes

Manual tasks like sending invoices or tracking renewals drain time and resources, and there is a high chance of errors. A 94% of companies perform repetitive, time-consuming tasks, which means manual tasks are a challenge almost everywhere and make operations either slow or inefficient.

For example, you are manually processing membership renewals, so you must send individual reminders, track payments, and update records one by one. 

This process will first consume significant time, energy, and resources for you and your team. It will also increase the likelihood of errors, such as missed payments or inaccurate member data, which will further slow down the process.

Demonstrating Value

Another challenge is the demonstration of your value to your members. You invest time and resources and create a package of value and benefits for your members tailored to their needs, but it’s not enough. 

Don’t assume they’ll automatically recognize those efforts and stay. Rather, you have to make your value impossible to miss and clearly show them what you are doing for them.

For example, if your organization offers networking opportunities, simply stating that as a benefit isn’t enough. Members need to see tangible examples, like successful collaborations or testimonials from other members who benefited from those opportunities. 

If members can’t see the value you’re providing or how it directly addresses their problems, they may feel their needs are not being addressed and start looking elsewhere for solutions. 

It’s not just about creating benefits; it’s about effectively communicating them. The real challenge lies in making those benefits crystal clear and making sure members understand how your organization solves their challenges and meets their expectations. 

Without this clarity, retaining members becomes an ongoing struggle.

Recruiting New Members

Image

Attracting new members is not easy and has become one of the biggest challenges for organizations today. Many find it increasingly difficult to grow their membership base in a highly competitive environment. 

For example, 21% of associations saw their membership decrease, while 31% remained the same in the past year. These numbers reflect the significant challenge organizations face when trying to recruit new members.

Recruiting new members isn’t just about reaching out; it’s about standing out. Growing competition, where countless organizations offer similar benefits, makes it harder to differentiate yourself. 

At the same time, a lack of perceived value in what’s being offered, ineffective marketing efforts, and the inability to clearly identify and target the right audience often compound the problem.

Communication Gaps

When communication is irregular or irrelevant, your members may feel disconnected and unvalued. They might question the purpose of their membership and feel isolated from your organization, leading to disengagement and, eventually, their decision to leave.

A communication gap is one of your biggest challenges. Without consistent and meaningful updates, members feel uninformed and overlooked, which weakens their connection to your organization. 

When members don’t see the value of staying engaged, frustration grows, eroding trust and loyalty.

This issue affects not only individual members but also the overall sense of community you’ve worked to build. Ignoring it can result in declining engagement and retention, ultimately threatening your organization’s success.

Financial Management

Managing payments, dues, and budgets without proper tools is a challenge you don’t need. Delayed payments, missed deadlines, and disorganized records create chaos, leaving you overwhelmed. 

When systems fail or are inefficient, tracking member contributions, reconciling accounts, and maintaining budgets can become out of control.

For your organization, handling finances may be one of the biggest challenges. Errors in payment records or budgets don’t just frustrate; they cause lost revenue, damage relationships with members, and make future planning difficult. 

Even small mistakes escalate into larger issues, such as misallocated funds or payment disputes, adding unnecessary stress.

Low Participation in Events

You’ve planned a fantastic event, but attendance is disappointingly low. Does that sound familiar? For your organization, low event participation can be one of the toughest challenges to handle. 

It’s not just about empty seats. It often points to deeper issues, like poor promotion, irrelevant content, or low engagement with your members.

When your members don’t feel connected to the event’s purpose or see the value it offers, they’re less likely to show up. Things like ineffective communication, bad timing, or competing priorities can make it even harder to draw a crowd. 

Each time participation falls short, it doesn’t just affect the event. It also impacts your efforts to build a sense of community and maintain strong member relationships.

Low attendance is not only disappointing but also undermines the time, energy, and resources you’ve invested, making it a frustrating and ongoing challenge.

Adapting to Technology

Adopting new tools can be intimidating, but sticking to outdated systems holds your organization back. Resistance to change is a challenge worth overcoming. For many organizations, the hesitation to adopt new technology stems from fears of disruption, lack of familiarity, or concerns about costs and training. 

These fears can lead to prolonged reliance on inefficient systems, which stifles growth and prevents the organization from keeping pace with competitors.

Clinging to outdated methods often results in wasted time, increased errors, and missed opportunities to improve processes. It’s not just a minor inconvenience; it can have long-term implications for efficiency and member satisfaction. 

Addressing these challenges head-on with thoughtful strategies and the right tools helps resolve these issues and sets your organization up for long-term success.

Solutions to Overcome These Challenges

Addressing membership challenges effectively requires actionable strategies and the right tools. 

Here’s how you can tackle these hurdles and create a more streamlined, member-focused organization:

Member Retention

Retention starts with understanding why members leave. To address this, here are some solutions you can implement tailored to your organization:

• Conduct surveys to gather insights on why members leave: you can send a short exit survey to members who don’t renew. Ask them about their experience, reasons for leaving, and any suggestions they might have. Using tools like Glue Up Surveys makes it easier for you to collect and analyze this feedback effectively.
• Use the collected data to develop programs offering personalized benefits and experiences: If your surveys show that members leave because of irrelevant content, you can introduce webinars or training sessions that match their professional interests. This helps you show that you’re listening to their needs.
• Implement loyalty programs to encourage long-term membership: Create a rewards system where members earn points for attending events or renewing their membership. You could let them redeem these points for perks like discounted tickets or exclusive resources.
• Create tailored communications to address individual member needs: Segment your audience and send personalized messages based on their interests. For instance, if you know some members prefer networking events, make sure they’re the first to hear about upcoming opportunities in their area.
• Provide exclusive member perks to keep members engaged and renewing: Offering perks like early access to events or member-only resources helps you make members feel special and appreciated. For example, you can give long-term members priority registration for high-demand events.

Member Engagement

Engagement is all about creating meaningful opportunities for members to interact. Here are some solutions to enhance engagement:

• Host networking events that cater to member interests: For example, organize industry-specific meetups or virtual coffee chats where members can connect and exchange ideas. Using Glue Up’s event management tools, you can easily plan, promote, and track these events.
• Offer webinars and discussion forums for knowledge sharing: Provide regular webinars featuring expert speakers or create online forums where members can discuss topics relevant to their profession. For instance, you could host a Q&A session with industry leaders, allowing members to gain insights and feel more involved.
• Incorporate gamification elements to encourage participation: Add features like points or badges for attending events, engaging in discussions, or completing surveys. For example, reward members with points that can be redeemed for perks like event discounts or exclusive content.
• Create exclusive groups or committees for deeper involvement: Offer members the chance to join committees or special interest groups that align with their professional goals. For instance, establish a leadership committee to help plan events or shape organizational initiatives.

Data Management

Managing data effectively is essential for running a successful organization. Here are some solutions you can implement to tackle common data management challenges:

• Centralize member data for better organization: For example, bringing all member information into a single CRM system helps you avoid fragmented data and ensures everyone on your team has access to the most up-to-date records.
• Regularly clean and audit your database: Conduct routine checks to remove duplicate entries and update outdated information. For instance, if you notice multiple profiles for the same member, consolidate them into a single, accurate record.
• Streamline data-sharing processes within your team: Ensure data is accessible to relevant team members while maintaining proper security. For example, provide access to event attendance data for event coordinators and financial records to the accounting team.
• Use data insights to make informed decisions: Generate reports to track member activity and engagement trends. For example, these insights can be used to identify inactive members and create targeted re-engagement campaigns.

Manual Processes

Relying on manual processes can lead to inefficiencies and errors, making it harder to focus on strategic goals. Here are some solutions to address this challenge:

• Automate repetitive tasks to save time and reduce errors: For example, use automation tools to send renewal reminders or generate invoices. Instead of manually tracking dues, let an automated system like Glue Up handle these tasks, ensuring nothing slips through the cracks.
• Consolidate tools to manage multiple tasks in one platform: Avoid juggling multiple systems by adopting integrated solutions. For instance, manage member communications, event planning, and invoicing from a single dashboard to improve productivity and reduce complexity.
• Simplify approval workflows for quicker processing: Set up automated workflows for membership applications or event registrations. For example, allow members to submit forms online and have approvals routed to the appropriate team automatically.
• Track task progress with real-time reporting: Use tools that provide updates on completed and pending tasks. For instance, monitor how many renewal reminders have been sent and follow up only where necessary.

Demonstrating Value

Effectively demonstrating value is essential for retaining members and keeping them engaged. Here are solutions to tackle this challenge:

• Leverage success stories and testimonials: Share real examples of how your organization has positively impacted members. For instance, highlight a member who landed a key business opportunity through one of your networking events, showcasing the tangible benefits of being part of your community.
• Provide regular updates to reinforce value: Keep members informed about the benefits they are receiving. For example, send a monthly newsletter detailing new resources, upcoming events, or recent accomplishments that align with their goals.
• Use data to showcase the impact of membership: Share statistics that illustrate member outcomes. For instance, highlight how many members accessed exclusive resources or how many participated in successful events, showing the value they’re gaining.
• Highlight opportunities for professional growth: Emphasize how your organization helps members achieve their goals. For example, share insights from webinars, job opportunities, or training sessions that align with their career aspirations.

Recruiting New Members

Bringing in new members is essential for growth but often presents challenges. Here are solutions to help with recruitment, along with actionable examples:

• Leverage referral programs to expand your reach: Encourage current members to bring in others by offering rewards or incentives. For example, provide discounts on membership renewals or exclusive perks for members who successfully refer new recruits.
• Use digital marketing to showcase your organization: Create targeted ads on platforms like LinkedIn, Facebook, or Google to reach potential members. For instance, highlight your organization’s unique benefits, such as networking opportunities or professional development resources, to grab attention.
• Develop compelling content that demonstrates value: Share success stories, testimonials, and industry insights through blogs, videos, and social media posts. For example, create a short video showcasing how your events helped members achieve their career goals.
• Streamline the onboarding process for new members: Make joining simple and engaging. For instance, send an automated welcome email with clear instructions on how to access resources, participate in events, and connect with other members.

Communication Gaps

Effective communication is crucial for member engagement, but gaps can lead to frustration and disengagement. Here are solutions to address communication gaps, along with actionable examples:

• Segment your audience for tailored messaging: Group members based on their interests, demographics, or engagement levels. For example, send event invitations to members in specific regions or industries, ensuring the content is relevant to them.
• Use email automation to keep members informed: Set up automated email campaigns for recurring updates like event reminders, renewal notices, or exclusive offers. For instance, send personalized birthday wishes or milestone congratulations to foster a sense of connection.
• Leverage social media for timely updates: Post regular updates about upcoming events, new resources, or member achievements. For example, create a Facebook group or LinkedIn page where members can stay informed and actively participate.
• Ensure consistency in your communication schedule: Establish a regular cadence for newsletters, announcements, or updates. For instance, send a monthly newsletter summarizing key events, resources, and member success stories.
• Encourage two-way communication for feedback: Create channels for members to share their input. For example, host live Q&A sessions or send surveys through Glue Up to understand their preferences and needs better.

Financial Management

Handling finances efficiently is critical for any organization, yet it often presents challenges. Here are solutions to improve financial management:

• Automate payment systems for smooth transactions: Set up systems that manage invoicing, reminders, and payment collection automatically. For example, use a management platform to send renewal reminders and track payments, reducing manual effort and errors.
• Maintain clear and accurate financial records: Ensure all transactions are recorded in an organized manner. For instance, categorize member payments, event fees, and sponsorship income separately to simplify tracking and auditing.
• Provide detailed financial reports to improve transparency: Share periodic reports with your team or members to build trust. For example, include a breakdown of where funds are allocated, such as event costs or new member benefits.
• Enable easy access to payment options for members: Offer multiple payment methods, such as credit cards, bank transfers, or digital wallets, to make it convenient for members to pay on time. For instance, integrate an online payment gateway directly into your membership platform.
• Plan budgets effectively to avoid financial strain: Use financial data to forecast expenses and income accurately. For example, analyze past trends to allocate sufficient resources for upcoming events or new programs.

Low Participation in Events

Low participation in events is a common challenge that can affect your organization’s engagement and success. Here are some solutions to address this issue:

• Send personalized invitations to increase relevance: Tailor event invites based on members’ interests or past attendance. For example, invite members who previously attended a similar workshop, highlighting how this event builds on that experience.
• Use targeted promotions to reach the right audience: Promote events on platforms like LinkedIn or email campaigns, focusing on specific member segments. For instance, advertise a networking event to professionals in a particular industry.
• Offer early-bird discounts to encourage sign-ups: Provide incentives for members who register early. For example, offer 10% off for the first 50 registrants to create urgency and excitement.
• Create engaging content to generate buzz: Share sneak peeks, testimonials from past events, or behind-the-scenes footage on social media. For instance, post a short video of a keynote speaker previewing their upcoming session.
• Conduct post-event surveys to gather feedback: Send a quick survey after each event to understand what attendees liked or where improvements are needed.

Adapting to Technology

Adapting to new technology is often a significant challenge for organizations, as it involves both technical adjustments and overcoming resistance to change. Here are some solutions to help with the transition:

• Provide proper training for your team to build confidence: Organize hands-on workshops or virtual training sessions to familiarize your team with new tools. For example, conduct a webinar to demonstrate how Glue Up’s CRM can simplify member data management and streamline workflows.
• Highlight the benefits of modern technology: Communicate how the new tools will make their jobs easier and more efficient. For instance, show how automating membership renewals saves time and reduces errors compared to manual tracking.
• Choose intuitive platforms to minimize resistance: Opt for tools with user-friendly interfaces that integrate seamlessly with existing systems. For example, select a platform that connects directly with your email marketing and event management tools to reduce the learning curve.
• Create a gradual rollout plan for smoother adoption: Introduce new tools in phases, starting with one department or feature at a time. For example, begin with automating invoices before expanding to full data management integration.
• Encourage feedback during the transition: Collect input from your team about what’s working and what challenges they face. For instance, surveys can be used to identify areas where additional support or training is needed.

Case Studies: Solving Membership Challenges

Image

Talking about solutions is one thing, but seeing real-world examples brings those solutions to life. Let’s look at how organizations like yours have overcome their membership challenges with innovative strategies and tools. 

These case studies show what’s possible when challenges are met with the right solutions.

Case Study 1

DNPs of Color faced significant challenges in managing their growing community, especially as they transitioned into a member-based association. With a mission to support Doctors of Nursing Practice of Color through networking, mentorship, and advocacy, efficient communication and streamlined operations became critical. 

Using Glue Up, DNPs of Color addressed these challenges by simplifying their membership processes and optimizing communication. Initially, the organization had only ten contacts. However, Glue Up’s intuitive CRM helped them grow their database to over 1,000 contacts within a year. The platform enabled them to automate membership applications, track growth, and maintain consistent engagement with members. 

Additionally, Glue Up’s event management software played a crucial role. It allowed DNPs of Color to organize and advertise events efficiently, saving time previously spent on manual registration and payment collection. Automated event reminders ensured higher participation and engagement from their members. 

The result was a transformed organization with streamlined processes that supported community-led growth. Glue Up’s all-in-one platform addressed DNPs of Color’s membership challenges and empowered the association to expand its reach and engagement effectively.

Case Study 2

Due to fragmented systems, CBAA faced significant challenges in managing memberships. They relied on multiple tools, including Excel spreadsheets, Memberplanet, Mailchimp, and Eventbrite, which led to inconsistencies and inefficiencies in tracking data, collecting dues, and communicating with members.

Glue Up helped CBAA streamline its operations by integrating membership management, event registration, and communication into one platform. This unified approach simplified administrative tasks and reduced errors. 

Key features like an automated membership directory, reminders, and real-time engagement metrics allowed CBAA to efficiently track memberships, including discounts for students, and analyze member activity for better decision-making.

Since implementing Glue Up, CBAA has seen measurable improvements in membership retention and event attendance. Centralized data management minimized the manual workload, improved communication, and fostered a stronger connection with members, helping the organization achieve its goals effectively.

Solving Membership Issues with Glue Up

Image

Glue Up is an all-in-one AI-powered membership management solution designed to simplify complex processes and boost efficiency. It offers a comprehensive set of features tailored to the unique needs of organizations managing memberships, events, and communications. 

Here’s how you can capitalize on Glue Up’s capabilities to make membership management a breeze.

Digital Applications & Flexible Membership Options

Simplify the onboarding process with custom online forms and automatic data synchronization. Prospective members can join effortlessly, making recruitment seamless and organized.

Automated Renewals and Recurring Payments

Streamline membership retention with customizable workflows, recurring payment options, and automated reminders. Make sure no renewal is missed, reducing administrative efforts and maintaining consistent communication.

Community Engagement Tools

Private and public groups, 1-on-1 direct chats, and digital business cards enable members to interact and collaborate effectively. These features create a connected and vibrant community, building higher engagement.

Event Management Integration

Manage online and offline events with ease using custom registration forms, premium branding options, and secure payment solutions. Make event execution smooth and boost attendance, offering members engaging and professional experiences.

Branded Emails & Automated Alerts

Keep your communication relevant and timely with branded email campaigns and automated notifications. Streamlined campaigns maintain consistent updates and help bridge communication gaps while keeping members informed.

Real-Time Insights & Analytics

Gain detailed data about member activities, renewals, and engagement history. With actionable insights at your fingertips, make data-driven decisions and tackle data management challenges effectively.

Mobile Management Access

Manage memberships, events, and payments from anywhere using Glue Up’s Manager App. Features like engagement analytics and ticket scanning provide continuity and efficiency, eliminating manual hassles.

Networking Tools

Enhance member connections with tools like 1-on-1 direct chats and digital business cards. These features prioritize meaningful member relationships and increase the overall value of your community.

Centralized Data & CRM

Consolidate all member information in one place with Glue Up’s built-in CRM functionality. Simplify the management of large databases, minimize errors, and improve decision-making processes.

Surveys and Feedback Tools

Collect valuable insights from members through surveys and feedback tools to refine your offerings and improve engagement. These tools make sure your organization remains responsive to member needs and expectations.

Discover how Glue Up can transform your membership management and strengthen relationships within your community. Book a demo today to see the difference!